Why are shy guys CONFUSING as hell?

You do like the shy guys. I was a little worried when u said he opened up emotionally and cut down the physical stuff. My first thought was he might like you as a friend. But the looking into your eyes thing made me realize he is probably more comfortab;e opening up emotionally then physically. And the pillow thing was similar to a thing I did with a girl last year where I'd throw pillows and shoot her with a nerf gun till she was near enough me where I couldn't. She ended up eventually ignoring me for my roomate, so I wish you better luck. But I think he does like you. Again, might be up to you to make thr first step. Glad to see there are girls who are attracted to shy guys:)